Best 85 Pizzerias in New York, according to study

Top 85 Pizza Places in New York

Think of this as a "Pizzeria Of The Month" contest. Except here, a jury didn't get to choose who gets what. This time, we allowed all the 19,618,323 people living in New York to be jurors by picking up various signals they created, including reviews, online & offline sentiment metrics, citations, Google search result rankings, links between websites, brand mentions, social media activity, and more.

Essentially, this competition focuses on the passion for creating delicious pizza. We discovered and reviewed all the 1,957 pizza parlorls in New York, then shortlisted the most relevant 85 ones (pizza chains, small pizzerias, pizza delivery services, etc.) and ranked them according to their menu variety, quality of ingredients, customer service, and overall dining experience.

Unlock an unfair competitive advantage by subscribing to our newsletter, packed with unique New York pizza market insights and business intelligence!

Updated: April 28, 2024

Home → Blog → Side-by-side comparison of the best pizza parlors in New York

Changed your mind?

Pizza places, ranked by the good people of New York

Rank	Domain	PopulationServed	Visibility	AveragePosition	Pages	Rankings	ZIPs	Top3	Top10
#1	imperialpizzabuffalo.com	275,210	1.4%	98.4	1	50	50	0	43
#2	bkpizza.nyc	240,002	1.2%	98.9	1	43	43	0	12
#3	salvatores.com	197,946	1.0%	97.8	14	84	83	0	50
#4	wiseguysbuffalo.com	174,877	0.9%	98.6	1	47	47	0	36
#5	guidaspizzeria.com	124,526	0.6%	97.6	1	122	122	0	41
#6	caragliospizza.com	115,437	0.6%	96.4	1	185	185	0	20
#7	johnspizzaqueens.com	109,641	0.6%	98.3	1	56	56	0	1
#8	barboncinopizza.com	96,331	0.5%	99.7	1	29	29	0	2
#9	aznypdpizza.com	74,443	0.4%	92.7	1	212	212	0	0
#10	francospizza.com	72,512	0.4%	93.8	3	273	272	0	11
#11	tonystakeout.net	72,105	0.4%	98.9	1	45	45	0	7
#12	eastvillagepizza.net	69,045	0.4%	98.7	2	135	134	0	2
#13	justpizzausa.com	64,725	0.3%	85.3	2	706	705	0	3
#14	saratogapizza7.com	64,174	0.3%	100.1	1	25	25	1	8
#15	ciaoithaca.com	56,206	0.3%	100.4	1	13	13	0	9
#16	patspizzas.com	55,423	0.3%	99.8	5	34	33	0	17
#17	lennyspizzanyc.com	53,791	0.3%	98.9	1	56	56	0	1
#18	seasonspizza.com	53,562	0.3%	91.1	2	366	366	0	0
#19	mycharliespizza.com	52,432	0.3%	99.5	2	30	28	1	23
#20	pauliespizzany.com	50,728	0.3%	100.5	1	9	9	0	9
#21	allstar-pizza.com	49,438	0.3%	98.6	1	50	50	0	2
#22	mineossouth.com	45,940	0.2%	98.7	2	50	47	0	10
#23	joespizzanyc.com	45,416	0.2%	94.6	1	159	159	0	0
#24	defaziospizza.com	45,263	0.2%	100.7	1	5	5	0	5
#25	firstpizza.com	45,161	0.2%	94.3	1	190	190	0	0
#26	bayridgepizza.com	43,974	0.2%	100.6	1	9	9	0	1
#27	myoip.com	41,712	0.2%	93.3	1	381	381	0	4
#28	lapizzaclub.com	40,039	0.2%	98.8	1	45	45	0	4
#29	townepizzaschenectady.com	39,893	0.2%	100.5	1	9	9	0	9
#30	villamontepizza.com	37,631	0.2%	100.4	1	12	12	0	1
#31	pizzaclassicutica.com	36,758	0.2%	98.6	1	78	78	0	19
#32	amante.pizza	35,890	0.2%	100.7	1	6	6	0	2
#33	patsyspizzeriaofqueens.com	35,603	0.2%	98.7	1	55	55	0	0
#34	totonnosconeyisland.com	35,168	0.2%	99.1	1	44	44	0	0
#35	ninospizzabrooklyn.com	35,133	0.2%	99.4	1	37	37	0	0
#36	fmpizzeria.com	34,915	0.2%	89.5	1	808	808	0	0
#37	joeyspizzeria.net	34,335	0.2%	100.0	1	33	33	0	9
#38	emilianospizza.com	33,714	0.2%	100.8	1	4	4	0	2
#39	gennarospizzaparlor.com	32,700	0.2%	100.5	1	9	9	0	6
#40	joesbrooklynpizza.com	32,442	0.2%	97.8	4	75	75	0	0
#41	brooklynspizzaco.com	31,768	0.2%	99.4	2	36	36	0	0
#42	pizzazpizza.com	31,108	0.2%	99.2	1	36	36	0	3
#43	paesanspizza.com	31,007	0.2%	94.0	6	220	218	0	14
#44	nynypizzeria.com	29,257	0.1%	98.3	1	129	129	0	0
#45	vincenzospizzaelmira.com	29,124	0.1%	100.3	1	20	20	2	8
#46	joeandpatsny.com	28,987	0.1%	100.4	1	12	12	0	1
#47	brandanispizza.com	28,764	0.1%	98.9	1	43	43	0	1
#48	pizzaofnewyork.com	28,694	0.1%	98.6	1	50	50	0	3
#49	tkspizzaonline.com	28,464	0.1%	100.9	1	2	2	0	1
#50	empirepizzaglensfalls.com	27,963	0.1%	95.3	1	191	191	0	10
#51	perrispizza.com	26,693	0.1%	97.4	5	131	130	0	2
#52	glpizza.com	26,462	0.1%	100.4	1	15	15	0	1
#53	bellapizza.com	26,202	0.1%	96.0	1	133	133	0	2
#54	sergiosnypizza.com	26,013	0.1%	100.4	2	15	15	0	1
#55	giuseppespizzashopmenu.com	25,995	0.1%	100.0	1	20	20	0	16
#56	sottocasanyc.com	25,966	0.1%	97.0	3	135	135	0	0
#57	pizzaexpressny.net	25,672	0.1%	100.3	1	17	17	0	5
#58	ferrosfamousnypizza.com	25,431	0.1%	99.5	1	46	46	0	2
#59	ossiningpizzeria.com	25,423	0.1%	100.9	1	2	2	1	1
#60	leospizzeriaonline.com	24,933	0.1%	98.6	2	60	59	0	5
#61	pizzastopny.com	24,619	0.1%	100.6	1	13	13	0	1
#62	madisonspizza.com	24,263	0.1%	99.9	1	22	22	0	10
#63	regentspizza.com	24,159	0.1%	94.6	1	655	655	0	0
#64	mariospizzeria.com	23,710	0.1%	100.8	3	4	4	0	3
#65	rosaliapizzeria.com	23,706	0.1%	100.7	1	7	7	0	1
#66	antoniosbrooklyn.com	23,664	0.1%	99.5	1	37	37	0	0
#67	mamaspizza.nyc	23,470	0.1%	96.7	1	99	99	0	1
#68	sicilianpizzaschenectady.com	23,092	0.1%	100.5	1	9	9	0	2
#69	francospizzananuetny.com	22,918	0.1%	100.8	1	4	4	0	1
#70	numero28.com	22,771	0.1%	99.3	2	61	61	0	0
#71	michelangelosristorante.com	22,418	0.1%	100.0	1	22	22	0	13
#72	julianaspizza.com	22,221	0.1%	99.6	1	37	37	0	0
#73	mypizzaunion.com	21,995	0.1%	100.9	1	1	1	0	1
#74	pizzamoto.com	21,682	0.1%	99.6	1	37	37	0	0
#75	mariospizzawp.com	21,284	0.1%	100.7	1	6	6	0	5
#76	marinosflyingpizza.com	21,225	0.1%	100.5	1	9	9	0	1
#77	europizzeria.net	20,700	0.1%	100.4	2	15	15	0	2
#78	vinniesbrooklyn.com	20,550	0.1%	99.7	1	37	37	0	0
#79	brooklynpizzadenver.com	20,267	0.1%	99.7	1	37	37	0	0
#80	binghamtonpizzeria.com	19,826	0.1%	100.0	1	20	20	0	6
#81	oipelmiracorning.com	19,332	0.1%	100.2	2	21	17	0	7
#82	pizzabarnyonkers.com	19,211	0.1%	100.4	1	70	70	0	0
#83	brooklynpizzaparlors.com	19,131	0.1%	100.0	2	38	38	0	0
#84	atlaspizzeria.com	19,062	0.1%	100.5	1	12	12	0	7
#85	asliceofbrooklyn.com	18,896	0.1%	99.8	1	37	37	0	0

What next? Let's see how SEOlium can help your business.

If you own, manage, or work for a pizza restaurant, this section is for you.

Want your backlink switched from nofollow to 'dofollow'? Drop us a message at info@seolium.com.
Need help with improving your metrics above (SEO consultancy & implementation)? Feel free to reach out at info@seolium.com.
Have an in-house SEO team? Our 99.7% accurate local Google rank tracking tool will help you track & report everything properly.

Interested in the New York pizza industry dynamics (market fluctuations, trends & emerging players, month-to-month movements)?